The Immaculata High School and Madison Square Boys & Girls Club Connection
Published on Wednesday, September 23, 2026
Former students of Immaculata High School in New York City may have questions about activities that took place outside the school's campus, including whether students used facilities connected with the Madison Square Boys & Girls Club. Those questions may be especially important in light of allegations involving Dr. Reginald Archibald, a physician who was associated with Madison Square Boys & Girls Club and who has been accused in civil litigation of sexually abusing children during medical examinations.
Immaculata High School was located at 317 East 33rd Street in Manhattan and closed in 1989. Historical information identifies the school as having been operated by the Sisters, Servants of the Immaculate Heart of Mary.
Information provided to PSGG Law indicates that Immaculata students may have used the Madison Square Boys & Girls Club because of the school's available athletic facilities. If that connection is confirmed through former student accounts, school records, yearbooks, or other historical evidence, it may be relevant to former Immaculata students who remember visiting the Club or participating in activities there.
The publicly available legal record concerning Dr. Archibald primarily concerns boys who participated in Madison Square Boys & Girls Club programs. For that reason, former Immaculata students should not assume that the allegations involving Archibald necessarily involved them. At the same time, a former student who remembers an examination, medical screening, or contact with Dr. Archibald may wish to learn more about what occurred and whether records exist that could clarify the circumstances.
What Was the Connection Between Immaculata High School and Madison Square Boys & Girls Club?
The precise historical relationship between Immaculata High School and Madison Square Boys & Girls Club requires further documentation.
According to information provided to PSGG Law, Immaculata students may have used Madison Square Boys & Girls Club facilities because the high school did not have a gymnasium or adequate facilities for certain activities. Former students may therefore remember traveling from the school at East 33rd Street to another location for physical education, athletics, recreation, or other school-related activities.
The Madison Square Boys & Girls Club operated a clubhouse on East 29th Street in Manhattan beginning in 1939. The organization's own historical account states that its first youth-dedicated facility opened on 29th Street that year.
The distinction between a confirmed historical fact and an individual recollection is important. The publicly available sources reviewed for this article do not independently establish the extent to which Immaculata students used Madison Square Boys & Girls Club facilities.
Former students who remember these activities may possess information that could help clarify the historical connection.
Why Is This Connection Significant?
The potential connection matters because of the allegations concerning Dr. Reginald Archibald and Madison Square Boys & Girls Club.
New York court records describe litigation in which former members of Madison Square Boys & Girls Club alleged that Archibald sexually abused them as children. In one appellate decision, the underlying plaintiffs alleged that Archibald, described as a former volunteer for the Club, and another individual sexually abused children and that the Club failed to properly supervise individuals who had access to children.
More recent New York court decisions have likewise addressed allegations concerning Archibald's medical examinations of young boys associated with Madison Square Boys & Girls Club. One 2025 decision described allegations that Archibald provided medical screenings and other medical services to young boys participating in a Club program.
These are allegations made in civil litigation. They should not be treated as findings that every allegation has been proven.
For former Immaculata students, however, the existence of this litigation may raise understandable questions if they remember using Madison Square Boys & Girls Club facilities or receiving medical examinations associated with activities there.
Who Was Dr. Reginald Archibald?
Dr. Reginald Archibald was a physician affiliated with Rockefeller University who has been identified in lawsuits and public reporting concerning alleged sexual abuse of children.
Court records describe allegations that Archibald provided medical examinations to young people associated with Madison Square Boys & Girls Club. In some cases, plaintiffs have alleged that examinations that were presented as medical or research-related went beyond legitimate medical purposes and constituted sexual abuse.
A federal court has also addressed claims alleging that Madison Square Boys & Girls Club negligently supervised or retained Archibald, allowing allegations against him to proceed in part at the motion-to-dismiss stage. The court's decision concerned the legal sufficiency of the claims and was not a final determination that every allegation had been proven.
These cases have brought renewed attention to questions about how children were examined, who supervised those examinations, what institutions knew, and what steps were taken when concerns arose.
Were Immaculata Students Examined by Dr. Archibald?
There is currently insufficient publicly available evidence to state that Immaculata High School students were examined by Dr. Archibald.
That point is important.
The existing lawsuits and court decisions located for this article describe allegations involving boys connected to Madison Square Boys & Girls Club. They do not establish that students from Immaculata High School were among Archibald's patients.
However, former Immaculata students may have information that is not reflected in publicly available records.
A former student who remembers being examined at a Madison Square Boys & Girls Club facility, being referred to a physician through a school-related program, or having an examination that raised questions may wish to preserve those memories and discuss them with an attorney.
What Might Former Immaculata Students Remember?
For someone who attended Immaculata decades ago, memories may be incomplete. That does not necessarily mean they are irrelevant.
Former students may remember:
- Traveling to another facility for physical education or school activities
- Visiting the Madison Square Boys & Girls Club
- Participating in athletic or recreational programs there
- Being told to undergo a physical or medical examination
- Being examined separately from other students
- Meeting a physician whose name they later learned was Dr. Reginald Archibald
- Discussing an examination with classmates
- Being uncomfortable or confused about something that happened during an examination
- Remembering teachers, administrators, coaches, or other adults who arranged or supervised activities
A person does not need to remember every detail before seeking legal advice.
Names, approximate dates, school years, classmates, locations, photographs, yearbooks, letters, medical records, and other documents may help an attorney investigate what happened.
Why Former Students May Have Questions Today
Many people who experienced inappropriate conduct as children do not immediately understand what happened.
A child may assume that an adult's actions are appropriate because the adult is a physician, teacher, coach, administrator, or another trusted authority figure. A young person may also lack the knowledge or language necessary to question an examination at the time it occurs.
The passage of time can make those experiences even more difficult to evaluate.
Former students may only later encounter information about allegations involving a person they remember from childhood. Learning about those allegations can lead someone to reconsider an experience that had remained unexplained for many years.
That does not mean that every childhood medical examination was improper or that every person who remembers Archibald experienced abuse. Each individual's circumstances must be evaluated separately.
What Evidence Could Help Establish the Historical Connection?
Because Immaculata High School is now closed, former students may wonder where historical information could be found.
Potential sources of information may include:
- Immaculata High School yearbooks
- School records
- Physical education records
- Class photographs
- Student schedules
- Medical or physical examination records
- Madison Square Boys & Girls Club records
- Correspondence between the school and outside organizations
- Testimony from former classmates
- Testimony from former teachers or administrators
- Historical complaints
- Court records and prior litigation
The existing Madison Square Boys & Girls Club litigation demonstrates the importance of historical records and testimony when allegations concern events that occurred many decades ago. In one recent New York decision, the court discussed allegations concerning institutional knowledge and supervision of Archibald and noted that information about internal records and prior complaints could be relevant during litigation.
Former students should therefore not assume that the absence of personal records means there is nothing to investigate.
Could an Institution Be Held Responsible?
Depending on the circumstances, a civil claim arising from childhood sexual abuse may involve questions concerning institutions as well as the individual accused of abuse.
Potential claims may involve issues such as negligent hiring, negligent supervision, negligent retention, failure to protect children, or failure to respond appropriately to known concerns.
New York courts have considered allegations that Madison Square Boys & Girls Club failed to properly supervise Archibald despite alleged warning signs. In 2025, a New York court allowed certain negligence claims involving alleged abuse by Archibald to proceed beyond the dismissal stage.
Whether an institution can be held legally responsible depends on the facts, available evidence, applicable law, and circumstances of the particular case.
What If an Immaculata Student Believes Something Happened?
A former student does not need to determine independently whether an experience constituted sexual abuse before speaking with an attorney.
If someone remembers an examination or other interaction that now raises concerns, the first step may simply be documenting what they remember.
Useful details may include:
- The approximate year or school grade
- The location where the event occurred
- The names of teachers or other adults involved
- Names of classmates who may have been present
- What students were told about the purpose of the examination
- Whether the examination occurred at school or another facility
- Whether Madison Square Boys & Girls Club was involved
- The name of any physician remembered from the experience
Even uncertain memories can provide starting points for an investigation.
Former Immaculata Students May Have Questions About Their Experiences
The possible connection between Immaculata High School and Madison Square Boys & Girls Club deserves careful historical investigation.
The available public court records establish that serious allegations have been made concerning Dr. Reginald Archibald's examinations of children associated with Madison Square Boys & Girls Club. They do not, however, establish that Immaculata students were among those children.
For former Immaculata students who remember using Madison Square Boys & Girls Club facilities or undergoing a medical examination connected to school activities, those memories may raise important questions.
PSGG Law can help former students understand what information may be relevant, investigate potential institutional connections, and determine whether current New York law may provide a legal avenue based on the individual's circumstances.
Speaking with an attorney does not require a person to file a lawsuit. A confidential consultation can simply provide an opportunity to discuss what happened, understand potential legal options, and determine whether additional investigation may be appropriate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where was Immaculata High School located?
Immaculata High School was located at 317 East 33rd Street in Manhattan, New York City. The school subsequently closed. Available historical sources identify June 1989 as the school's closing date.
Did Immaculata High School use Madison Square Boys & Girls Club facilities?
PSGG Law has received information indicating that Immaculata students may have used Madison Square Boys & Girls Club facilities. The publicly available sources reviewed for this article do not independently establish the full extent or dates of that relationship. Former students and historical records may provide additional information.
Was Dr. Reginald Archibald connected to Madison Square Boys & Girls Club?
Yes. New York court records describe Archibald as a former volunteer or physician associated with Madison Square Boys & Girls Club and discuss allegations concerning medical examinations of children participating in Club programs.
Were Immaculata students examined by Dr. Archibald?
The publicly available sources reviewed do not establish that Immaculata students were examined by Dr. Archibald. Former students who remember Archibald, Madison Square Boys & Girls Club, or medical examinations connected with school activities may wish to discuss their experiences with an attorney.
What if I only have a vague memory of an examination?
A vague memory may still provide a starting point for an investigation. Details such as the approximate year, location, classmates, teachers, and purpose of the examination may help identify potentially relevant records or witnesses.
Can I still speak with an attorney if the events happened decades ago?
Yes. An attorney can review the circumstances and explain how current New York law may apply. Historical claims can involve complex legal issues, including applicable filing deadlines and statutory provisions.
Do I have to file a lawsuit if I contact PSGG Law?
No. Speaking with an attorney can simply help a former student understand their circumstances and potential legal options. Whether any legal claim exists depends on the individual facts and applicable law.
Attorney Advertising
